Played its final performance on November 9th
"First rate thriller!" - Manhattan Digest
"Impressive. Couldn’t be more moving!" - Huffington Post
"Leaves you stunned. Highly recommended!" - NY Observer

About the Show

Based on the true story made famous on “This American Life”, Stalking the Bogeyman follows renowned journalist David Holthouse’s secret pursuit of justice for a crime hidden for 25 years. This new play explores the dangers of vengeance, the power of forgiveness, and the strength of family.

Cast & Creative

DAVID HOLTHOUSE (Original Story) is unrepentantly a gonzo journalist. His best-known work has been published in alternative weekly newspapers, including the Chicago ReaderVillage VoiceDenver WestwordAustin ChronicleMiami New Times and Phoenix New Times. His work has also appeared in Rolling StoneMen’s JournalThe Nation and other national magazines. He’s the winner of numerous journalism and literary non-fiction writing awards, and was senior writer and editor for the Southern Poverty Law Center team that in 2007 won the Utne Reader Independent Press Award for its work exposing right-wing extremism in the U.S. and Europe. Holthouse lives in Alaska.  You can contact him HERE.


MARKUS POTTER (Script Adaptation / Director) is the founder and producing artistic director of NewYorkRep. 
Directing and producing credits include Stalking the Bogeyman (North Carolina Stage Company), The Velocity of Autumn by Eric Coble (Broadway-St. James), Black Wizard/Blue Wizard by Dave Malloy and Eliza Bent (Incubator Arts), Why You Beasting (Best of FringeNYC – transferred to the Players theatre off-Broadway).  As an actor: The Guthrie Theatre, Long Wharf, Denver Center, ACT, Berkeley Rep, tour of Death of a Salesman with Christopher Lloyd, Cherry Lane, Cal Shakes, San Francisco Shakespeare Festival, Studio Theatre DC, Great Lakes Theatre Festival and many more. You can contact him at or @MarkusPotter on twitter.


MURPHY GUYER (Robert Holthouse / Emmit) most recently appeared on Broadway as Doc Golightly in Breakfast at Tiffany’s. Other Broadway credits include Glengarry Glen Ross with Al Pacino, Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown, Lincoln Center’s South Pacific and The Caine Mutiny Court Martial. Film credits include Feast of the Goat, Arthur, Jackal, Mercy Man and City Hall. On television he’s appeared in “House of Cards,” “Person of Interest,” “Blue Bloods,” “Mildred Pierce,” “Rubicon,” “Sopranos” and “Law & Order.”

ROXANNE HART (Carol/Dr. Levitt) Broadway: Passion (Tony nomination); The Devil’s Disciple; Loose Ends; Cheaters; Equus. Off Broadway/ Regional: Song Of Twilight; Salome opposite Al Pacino; Eden Lane; Toys In The Attic; Lips together, teeth Apart (Drama Logue Award); Digby (Theater World Award,Drama Desk nomination); Hedda Gabler; Much Ado About Nothing. Film: Wilde Salome; License To Wed; Letters From Iwo Jima; Art School Confidential; The Good Girl; Moonlight Mile; The Last Innocent Man; Once Around; Oh God, You Devil; Highlander; The Verdict. Television: numerous MOW’s, “Camille” on Chicago Hope and recurring roles in ,“Hung,” “Medium,”and “OZ.”

ERIK HEGER (Bogeyman) Broadway: End of the Rainbow. Off-Broadway: An Error of the Moon (Beckett Theater), Based on a Totally True Story (M.T.C.). Regional highlights: Guthrie (title role in Macbeth among others), Ahmanson, Baltimore CenterStage, La Jolla Playhouse, Seattle Rep, American Conservatory Theater, Shakespeare Santa Cruz. Film/television: Police State, The Shells, Upside Out, Henry Hinkle, “Michael J. Fox Show,” “Royal Pains,” “Smash,” “30 Rock,” “NYC 22,” “Blue Bloods,” “Damages,” “Law & Order,” ESPN 2 and all the now-defunct New York soaps. Training: MFA, ACT; BA, Colorado College. Erik has also released 3 albums of solo harp music.

JOHN HERRERA (Russ Crawford / Payaso / Coach Billy). Broadway: Original Neville in The Mystery of Edwin Drood (Tony nomination), Che in Evita, 1776, Camelot, Man of La Mancha and The Threepenny Opera. Off-Broadway: Kevin in In the Heights. Tours: Chess, Les Misérables, Angels in America. Regional: Rothko in Red, Anna in the Tropics, All’s Well that Ends Well. New indie film The House That Jack Built, “Romance, Romance” on A&E, “Law & Order: SVU” and most recently “Person of Interest.” Thanks to Ron.

RODERICK HILL (David Holthouse) most recently appeared in the world premiere of Smart People at The Huntington Theater. Broadway credits include Butley and Elton John’s Lestat.  Off-Broadway: Unnatural Acts (CSC), The Return of the Prodigal (Mint Theater), Mary Broome (Mint Theater), Trans-Euro Express (Irish Arts), The Irish Curse (Soho Playhouse), Cymbeline (RSC/TFNA). Regional: Long Wharf, The Huntington, Hartford Stage, Roundhouse, Playmaker’s Rep., Shakespeare & Company. Film/TV: Run All Night, King Kelly, The Heart Machine, Song One, Kinsey, Life Is What Happens…, Cosa Bella, “The Newsroom,” “Louie,”  “Unforgettable,” “Person of Interest,” “The Good Wife,” “Law & Order,” “Chappelle’s Show,” “Strangers With Candy.” Graduate: Juilliard School, Interlochen Arts Academy. 

KATE LEVY (Nancy Holthouse). B’way Tours:  On Golden Pond, The Graduate. New York:  Roundabout, MTC, The Mint, TACT, New Group.  Regional:  St. Louis Rep, Hartford Theaterworks, Hartford Stage, Arena Stage, Cincinnati Playhouse, Yale Rep, Cleveland Playhouse, Denver Center, Pioneer, Portland Center Stage, Alliance, O’Neill, many more. Television: “Elementary,” “Unforgettable,” “Blue Bloods,” “Royal Pains,” “Gossip Girl,” “The Good Wife,” “Onion News Network” and all three “Law & Orders.” Film: Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close, The Origins of War. Tufts Univ., BA, ACT, MFA.

DAVID GOLDSTEIN (Scenic Design) NYC: Apollo/Daphne (Scenic), Fabulous (Lighting), Sweet, Sweet Spirit (Scenic/Lighting). 10 productions in NYMF including Cloned!Stuck, The Water Dream (w/Anthony Rapp), Ghostlight (w/Rachel York, Daisy Egan). LA:  West Side Story, Elevator, Playground, Rocky Horror, Its Top Secret!  Regional:  NC Stage (Stalking the Bogeyman), WV Public Theatre (9to5, Anything Goes, All Shook Up), Allenberry Playhouse (39 Steps, Smokey Joes Café). Huge thanks to Markus.  RLYcore4.     

TRISTAN RAINES (Costume Design). Off-Broadway / New York: Bare (New World Stages), Tribes (Barrow Street Theatre/Centre Theatre Group-LA/La Jolla Playhouse), Donkey Punch (Soho Playhouse), Murder in the First (59E59), Falling (Minetta Lane), A Fable, Yosemite, Scarcity (Rattlestick Playwrights Theater), The House of Von Macramé (Bushwick Starr), Carnival Kids (Lesser America). Henry Hewes Design Award and IT Award Nominee 2013 for House of Von Macramé.

CORY PATTAK (Lighting Design). Revolution in the Elbow… (Minetta Lane), Handle with Care (Westside), Witnessed by the World (59E59), Skippyjon Jones (Theatreworks USA), This Side of Paradise (St. Clements), Unlocked, Nymph Errant, With Glee, The Blue Flower (Prospect Theatre) Regional: Old Globe, Goodspeed, Maltz Jupiter, KC Rep, Cap Rep, Arkansas Rep, Penguin Rep, Engeman. Associate: Newsies, Peter…Starcatcher, Heathers, Daddy Long Legs. Host of “in 1: the podcast.”

ERIK T. LAWSON (Sound Design & Original Music). New York: Sotto Voce (Theatre for the New City), Sawbones, Diamond Eater (HERE), Nun$ (Brave New World Rep.), Nomads, Victor Frange Presents Gas (Incubator Arts), Feeling (New Ohio). Additional: Pittsburgh Irish and Classical Theatre, Luna Stage, Cincinnati Playhouse in the Park. International Exhibitions: World Stage Design 2013 (Cardiff, UK), Prague Quadrennial 2011 (Prague, CZ). MFA Carnegie Mellon, School of Drama.

McCORKLE CASTING (Casting). Pat McCorkle of McCorkle Casting Ltd. has cast over 50 Broadway productions, 58 Off- Broadway productions, 21 national tours, 61 television projects, 51 feature films and over 43 regional theatres spanning a 35-year career. Countless actors she has cast have garnered Tony, Oscar, Emmy, Olivier, Obie and Artios awards. She is an active member of CSA (Casting Society of America). 

NEWYORKREP (Producer) is committed to developing and producing innovative new plays and musicals. We gravitate towards stories that reveal truths about the universe, stories that expose the travesty and beauty of human kind, stories that create empathy, thus changing the space in which we live.   We aim to create a more conscious and compassionate community by telling stories that educate, inform, enhance, stories that have a social, ethical and political relevance, work that is complicated, curious and provocative – stories that hit you in the gut.  We approach our work with optimism, earnestness, open hearts and remain unapologetic in our belief that we are changing people’s lives.   @NYrepTheatre

R. ERIN CRAIG / LA VIE PRODUCTIONS (Producer) is dedicated to developing, producing and managing new works, fostering new talent and attracting new audiences. Other current Theatrical projects include Mr. Rickey Calls a Meeting, Academy26 PebblesJane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, Himself and Nora and LIBERTY: A Monumental New Musical. Films: Bridesburg and How We Got Away With It. Member: The Broadway League, The Off-Broadway League, TRU, NYWIFT, League of Professional Theatre Women.

SOUMYO SARKAR (Producer) is the founding principal of Sūmit Capital, a thematic oriented equity hedge fund based out of New York. Most recently, Sarkar served as the managing director and founder/head of the Matched Book Arbitrage at Deutsche Bank and prior to that, the director and head of Equitech Proprietary trading of Credit Suisse. MBA from the University of Iowa’s Tippie School of Management; BTec from the BHU Institute of Technology in Varanasi, India.

DR. RACHEL BARDHAN (Co-Producer) is a Social Anthropologist and Founder of the Real Stories Gallery Foundation; a 501(c)3 charity that employs the arts to raise awareness of the sexual exploitation of boys & adolescent males.

WOLFSTONE PRODUCTIONS (Producer) Founded in 2013 by Ari Warshawsky and Peter Biertzer-Warshawsky, Wolfstone produces theatre on and off Broadway that confronts; opening the heart, mind and soul. Ari worked with the Theatre Guild on the pre-Broadway tour of R&H’s State Fair and continues to work on the support end of the theatre community in NYC. This is Peter and Ari’s debut as producers. “Many thanks to Markus and Erin for this incredible opportunity.”

JAMES SEILER & DAVID SMITH (Producers) previously produced The Velocity of Autumn on Broadway. They have a performing and management background in opera, concert work, theatre and ballet, and are excited to be part of the Bogeyman family.

KATHY HENDERSON (Associate Producer) has been a theater journalist for more than 30 years, including stints as Senior Editor at and founding Editor-in-Chief of InTheater magazine. She is delighted to make her producing debut with Stalking the Bogeyman.

AMY VAN NOSTRAND (Associate Producer) An actor for over 35 years in theater, film and television, she makes her theater producing debut with Stalking the Bogeyman.  She’s Associate Producer and Co-Producer respectively of the independent features Seven Girlfriends and Black Road, on the board of Weston Playhouse and a member of The Actors Center.

IAN KAHN (Associate Producer) has been working with his partner Kathleen Marshall (not the theater director) and her father Garry Marshall creating television shows in Los Angeles as part of Henderson Productions for the past three years. Currently as an actor he can be seen as General George Washington on AMC’s “Turn: Washington Spies.”